Wayne S. Walker

“…Though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow” (Isa.

INTRO.: A hymn which takes its title and thought from God’s plea to
Israel through the prophet Isaiah is “Though Your Sins Be As Scarlet”
(#313 in “Hymns for Worship Revised” and #611 in “Sacred Selections for
the Church”). The text was written by Mrs. Frances Jane Crosby
VanAlstyne, better known as Fanny J. Crosby (1820-1915). The tune
(Compassion or Crimson) was composed by William Howard Doane (1832-1915).
The song first appeared in the 1876 “Gospel Music” compiled for Biglow
and Main by Doane and Robert Lowry (1826-1899).

Unlike many other Crosby-Doane collaborations, this song had not
come into popular usage when it was discovered by George Coles Stebbins
(1846-1945). Impressed with its possible usefulness if some slight
changes were made, he found various unnecessary repetitions which he
eliminated without materially changing the author’s theme. The changes
were submitted to Doane, who cordially consented to its publication in
that form. Stebbins’s arrangement first appeared in the 1887 “Gospel
Hymns No. 5″ intended for soprano and tenor duet.

The song has been found in most of hymnbooks published for use among
churches of Christ in the latter part of the 20th century. In the 1937
“Great Songs of the Church No. 2” edited by E. L. Jorgenson and “Sacred
Selections” it appears as a soprano-tenor duet. In the 1948 “Christian
Hymns No. 2″ edited by L. O. Sanderson and “Hymns for Worship” it appears
as a soprano-alto duet. The 1992 “Praise for the Lord” edited by John P.
Wiegand uses an arrangement for all four parts made for the 1956 “Baptist
Hymnal” edited by Walter Hines Sims (b. 1907.

It has been used very effectively as an invitation hymn.

I. Stanza 1 makes the plea
“Though your sins be as scarlet, They shall be as white as snow;
Though your sins be as scarlet, They shall be as white as snow.
Though they be red like crimson, They shall be as wool.
Though your sins be as scarlet, Though your sins be as scarlet,
They shall be as white as snow, They shall be as white as snow.”
A. Sin is the most serious problem with which mankind must deal: Rom.
3.23, 6.23
B. Sin is here likened to scarlet, red, or crimson probably because it
is such a noticeable color: Josh. 2.18-21
C. In contrast, white is the symbol of purity probably because it
denotes that which has been washed and is clean: Ps. 51.7, Mk. 9.3

II. Stanza 2 offers the invitation
“Hear the voice that entreats you: O return ye unto God!
Hear the voice that entreats you: O return ye unto God!
He is of great compassion, And of wondrous love.
Hear the voice that entreats you, Hear the voice that entreats you:
O return ye unto God! O return ye unto God!”
A. God wants us to hear His voice as revealed in His word: Ps. 95.7
B. This voice entreats us to return unto God, just as He called upon
wayward Israel to return to Him: Jer. 3.12
C. We can be assured that we can return to Him because He is of great
compassion and love: Ps. 86.15

III. Stanza 3 explains the reason
“He’ll forgive your transgressions And remember them no more;
He’ll forgive your transgressions And remember them no more.
‘Look unto me, ye people,’ Saith the Lord your God!
He’ll forgive your transgressions, He’ll forgive your transgressions,
And remember them no more, And remember them no more.”
A. God has declared that He is willing to forgive our transgressions: 1
Jn. 1.9
B. And when God forgives our transgressions, He will remember them no
more: Heb. 8.12
C. Therefore, He calls upon us to look unto Him: Isa. 45.22

CONCL.: Fanny Crosby was well-known for her work among the missions of
New York City and elsewhere that were designed to help people who were
down and out to see their need of Christ. She wrote songs about the need
to seek the lost (“Rescue the Perishing”) and songs inviting the lost to
come to the Lord (“Jesus Will Give You Rest” and “Jesus Is Tenderly
Calling”). There is no greater message that we can tell a sinful world
than that “You can still be saved by the grace of God through the blood
of Christ upon obedience to the gospel, even ‘Though Your Sins Be As

Posted in


Articles Menu

Sermons Menu


Sunday Morning Bible Study

Sunday Morning Worship

Tuesday Evening Bible Study